Forum

You must be logged in to post Login Register


Lost Your Password?

Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

RPGA…why?

UserPost

3:28 pm
March 10, 2009


Pureheart1975

Error: Unable to create directory /homepages/15/d192882892/htdocs/tysoes/blog/DD/wp-content/uploads/2012/05. Is its parent directory writable by the server?
Veteran

posts 37

I really don't understand this whole thing with the RPGA.  Why are they forcing timed games?  Why not just post the adventure and let the players take it where it goes?  Why are people jumping on board for RPG games that don't lend themselves to real "role playing"?  Why not just play a video game if you're going to play all these RPGA games?

4:23 pm
March 10, 2009


Gryvon

Veteran

posts 31

They don't really force timed games, per se. It's really more like a classic Bush Administration firm suggestion. The short answer to your question is; I have no idea. I never saw the allure to RPGA myself. It really does seem to be some people's cup of tea, though.

From the player perspective, it lacks a lot of what D&D is supposed to be, IMHO, especially on the RP side.

From a GM persepective, it still lacks a lot of what D&D is supposed to be. I personally like the write my own campaigns/adventures and I view it as a creative outlet. Why a DM would want to use and re-use the same modules is beyond me. I mean… I understand not everyone has the creative talent to write their own adventures, but that is what the modules are for. But the same ones? That's kinda boring. A DM also has to go through this sort-of boot camp and take a test afterward to be an "approved DM." No thank you. I'm a student. I take quite enough tests, thank you very much.

4:37 pm
March 10, 2009


SkilGalen

Admin

posts 59

I gave it some thought and the only solution I could come up with to the question is that a lot of people just don't have the time to invest in a proper regular game of D&D. 

A lot of us are in our 30's , 40's etc have a bunch of commitments and responsibilities and can't invest the time in forming a group and playing regularly. (I'm not one of them, but only because I convinced my wife to give it a go).

That plus the whole money thing again.. It's a lot easier to hold a tournament and control things if games are structured to fit in slots. Makes it easier for businesses with regular opening hours to schedule games so gamestores can host and set fees for a 4 hour session.

It also means you can just bring a character to any game and sit in a one time slot. Never have to face those players again. 

To be honest I don't care for any of it, it's definately convenience gaming and though I understand it it's one of the things that put me off the meetup group somewhat. If it was all RPGA I doubt I'd be playing, fortunately Russel Vance (the home made miniatures man) was at my first meetup group, I sat at the table and he was doing his own thing with whoever walked in. The game went well and we met up the following day and have done just about every sunday since.

I can't understand using the same modules either. Doesn't really suit me from a player or once having been a DM perspective. It would be like reading the same book over and over or the same movie. If the story and plot stays the same, and each time you have new players that don't know one another, how do you build a team that can work creatively together at solving problems and getting through situations. Seems like everyone will be playing for themselves and collecting what loot they can find to build up their stats and loot for later games. 

4:40 pm
March 10, 2009


SkilGalen

Admin

posts 59

I guess the positive side is that anyone can walk in and play, and you get more gamers around. And for wizards at least, the more people gaming the more books get sold, the more time and money they can invest in developing their product further.

It does seem to go against the fundamental grain of those things I typically enjoy most about D&D though.

5:55 pm
March 10, 2009


Paranitis

Sacramento (Rosemont), CA

Veteran

posts 46

Yep. 4E to me seems like it'd be WoW with dice, and then RPGA being involved makes me think exactly of grabbing 4 other random douchebags, running a dungeon for a possible loot drop, then not playing with them anymore.

You start the game not caring about anyone but yourself, and you leave the game not knowing anything else about anyone, and that's kinda how the whole thing is set up for. They want people to find dungeon groups with random people in real life and never talk to those people anymore.

6:01 pm
March 10, 2009


SkilGalen

Admin

posts 59

I'd say RPGA was like WOW with dice. I never played WOW but did try LOTR online and figure thats much the same thing. 4E is whatever you make of it really, you can play it like old D&D or RPGA it's really up to the players do play how they want to play.


About the forum

Most Users Ever Online: 17

Currently Online:
6 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3
Forums: 7
Topics: 30
Posts: 274

Membership:

There are 210 Members
There have been 7 Guests

There is 1 Admin

Top Posters:

Matt_R – 69
Paranitis – 46
Pureheart1975 – 37
Gryvon – 31
Odd_Canuck – 24
Druid – 1

Recent New Members: Druid, FailSword, MathewsMiranda21, whiskeyfur

Administrators: SkilGalen (59 Posts)



Use the form below to search the site: